They leave from both ends of the river, so an Abu Simbel tour built this way is available whichever city you reach first. The direction is the main practical difference: the Aswan departures sail downstream and finish in Luxor, the Luxor departures sail upstream and finish in Aswan. The stops are the same places in reverse order, and nothing in the data says one direction is better than the other.
The cheapest of them is $580, four days from Aswan, rated 4.5 on 533 reviews. Its description is also the most specific of them: it names Philae, Kom Ombo, Edfu and Abu Simbel, finishes in Luxor with a balloon morning and the West Bank, and states that an Egyptologist guides throughout. If you want an Aswan Abu Simbel tour with the itinerary spelled out rather than implied, that is the listing where it is spelled out.
At $643 the same four days are sold as a private sailing with your own guide, rated 4.2 on 260 reviews, and its description names the temples, Karnak and the Valley of the Kings, so a Karnak temple tour is written into that sailing rather than bought separately. That is the one to look at if you want to book Abu Simbel private tour arrangements rather than join a group, and the difference against the $580 listing is what going private costs on this river.
$686 buys four days from Aswan with Philae, the temples and the Valley of the Kings named, and it carries the second strongest rating of the group at 4.6 on 76 reviews — a good score on a modest number of reviews, which is a different thing from a good score on 533 of them.
From the Luxor end, $1,000 is three days with a private guide and the shortest Luxor Abu Simbel tour of the group, rated 4.2 on 169 reviews; its description names the Valley of the Kings, Karnak Temple, Edfu, Kom Ombo and the temples. $1,343 is five days, rated 4.2 on 185 reviews, and its description puts the balloon morning and the temples in the same sailing. $1,772 is seven days and the most expensive trip on the whole site, rated 4.7 on 10 reviews, which is the highest score of the group on the fewest reviews of the group.